Link to Zoom Recording: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1jD8jhriOqA

‘Life must be understood backwards… but… it must be lived forwards.’ Søren Kierkegaard, Journals 164 (1843)

The Abbott government’s Community Development Program (CDP) was announced as a replacement for the Gillard government’s Remote Jobs and Communities Program in December 2014. The program’s design was controversial from the outset as it was based in part on recommendations contained in the Review of Indigenous Employment and Training Programs Creating Parity chaired by mining magnate Andrew Forrest. The program operated in 60 regions in remote and very remote Australia and has had between 25,000 and 40,000 participants, over 80 per cent Indigenous. The key innovative feature of the program was its heavy-handed deployment of mutual obligations and financial penalties: the CDP architecture and co-opted providers were far more efficient in penalising the unemployed for non-compliance than in creating employment opportunities. Its sudden demise in the 2021-22 ‘Covid’ Budget context was unexpected and largely unexplained despite CDP’s broad unpopularity.

In response to these events, a small workshop was convened at the ANU in July 2021 to explore future options after CDP. Subsequently, the four of us co-authored a discussion paper quickly published by The Australia Institute in August that looked to outline some principles that might guide the development of a new livelihood and work program in remote Indigenous Australia. In September we presented our paper at another workshop convened with Indigenous stakeholders. We present the findings from our research and a subsequent jointly authored submission to a Senate Inquiry over two seminars.

In the second seminar, we present the seven principles that we developed to guide the co-design of the replacement program to CDP. Consultations are beginning around the future of social security payments in remote Australia. This is an opportunity to consider a more effective, caring and creative approach to supporting the health, wellbeing, and economic aspirations of Indigenous peoples in remote areas. Using our seven principles as an analytical guide, we conclude by critically discussing the emerging components of a revised policy approach, outlined in the Social Security Legislation Amendment (Remote Engagement Program) Bill 2021 and supporting documentation

Biographies

Zoe Staines is a Research Fellow with the School of Social Science, University of Queensland. She previously held research and policy positions in the Queensland public sector and, most recently, in the not-for-profit sector, as a Senior Policy Officer and Manager of Research. Since completing her PhD in criminology, she has published in the areas of policing, social policy, welfare conditionality, and rural/remote crime and governance. She was recently awarded an Australian Research Council Discovery Early Career Researcher Award (DECRA) (2020–2023) to further her work into remote community experiences of social policy and crime, and is also an Associate Editor of the Australian Journal of Social Issues.

Elise Klein is a Senior Lecturer of Public Policy at the Crawford School, ANU. Dr Klein has a DPhil in International Development from the University of Oxford and held a Post-Doctoral Fellowship at the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research (CAEPR) at the Australian National University. Her research interests include the rise of therapeutic cultures in policies, neoliberal subjectivities, economic rights, and decoloniality. Dr Klein has held various roles including working on the UN Secretary General’s High-Level Panel on Women’s Economic Development and the Human Rights Committee within the United Nations General Assembly. She was awarded the Medal of the Order of Australia (OAM) in 2019.

Francis Markham is an economic geographer and Research Fellow at the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research at the Australian National University. His research interests lie at the intersection of Indigenous public policy and Indigenous-state relations, focusing on issues such as land rights, wealth and reparations. Since 2019, he has been teaching Indigenous public policy to undergraduate students. Francis is currently engaged in a three-year participatory evaluation of the NSW Government’s flagship self-determination initiative, Local Decision Making.

Jon Altman is Emeritus Professor at the Australian National University in the School of Regulation and Global Governance. Jon established the Centre for Aboriginal Economic Policy Research at the ANU in 1990 and led it as foundation director for 20 years. Jon’s focus has been on enabling forms of lifeway practice that advocates for the need to recognise the right of Indigenous peoples to live differently, while simultaneously ensuring equality of treatment as Australian citizens. Jon has written on a wide range of issues including land rights and native title, appropriate forms of economic development, Indigenous communities and mining, tourism and the arts and the homelands movement.